Go to Start > Run and type secpol.msc and hit enter to launch it (if it's available). You're looking for Local Policies > Security Options > User Account Control: Behavior of the elevation prompt for administrators in Admin Approval Mode > Prompt for consent for ono-Windows binaries. The default option is "Elevate without prompting". Windows Servers has a similar option that doesn't mention "Admin Approval Mode" but it does the same thing.
But if your edition of Windows doesn't include secpol.msc you will have to do some registry hack to enable it.